West indian countries

Different WHO criteria for different countries: Government | India News

NEW DELHI: WHO’s analysis of global Covid deaths – reported by The New York Times – uses mortality figures directly obtained from a set of Tier I countries, while for Tier I countries II (including India), it uses a mathematical modeling process, the Health Ministry announced on Saturday.
In fact, it is not just India, specific issues have been raised by other WHO Member States like China, Iran, Bangladesh, Syria, Ethiopia and Egypt regarding the methodology and the use of “unofficial datasets”, the ministry said.
While putting the global toll at the end of 2021 at 15 million – adding 9 million to the count reported by individual countries – according to the NYT article, the WHO analysis indicates that a third of the additional deaths occurred in India. However, the NYT said it was unable to learn estimates for other countries.
“It is very surprising that while the New York Times could have allegedly obtained the alleged excess Covid-19 mortality figures compared to India, it was not ‘unable to learn the estimates for others. country,” the health ministry said.
Strongly criticizing the UN body for its methodology, the health ministry said the concern was specifically about how the statistical model projects estimates for a country the geographic size and population of India and also fits in with other countries, which have a smaller population. “Such an approach and one-size-fits-all models that are true for smaller countries like Tunisia may not be applicable to India with a population of 1.3 billion. The WHO has not yet shared the confidence interval of the current statistical model between the different countries,” he said.
Furthermore, the model yields two very different sets of excess mortality estimates when using data from Tier I countries and when using unverified data from 18 Indian states. “Such variation in estimates raises concerns about the validity and accuracy of such a modeling exercise,” the Department of Health said.
India and other member countries raised their concerns through a series of official communications, including six letters addressed to the WHO between November 17, 2021 and March 2, 2022. Questions were also raised. raised at various virtual meetings in December, January and February.
Questioning the approach followed by the WHO, the ministry said the model assumes an inverse relationship between monthly temperature and monthly average deaths, which has no scientific basis for establishing such a peculiar empirical relationship. Furthermore, the test positivity rate for Covid-19 in India has never been uniform across the country at any time, but this variation in the Covid-19 positivity rate in India has not been taken into account at for modeling purposes by WHO.


Source link